{"1070":{"title":"Rugby World Cup","uri":"rugby-world-cup","id":"111","oid":"210","ovid":"1070","order":0,"hasData":1},"1491":{"title":"Rugby's Greatest Rivalry","uri":"rugbys-greatest-rivalry","id":"1491","oid":"1491","ovid":"1491","order":1,"hasData":1},"0":{"title":"Autumn Nations Series","uri":"autumn-nations-series","id":"124","oid":"365","ovid":"0","order":31,"hasData":1},"2146":{"title":"Nations Championship","uri":"nations-championship","id":"114","oid":"114","ovid":"2146","order":3,"hasData":1},"1034":{"title":"World Rugby Junior World Championship","uri":"world-rugby-u20-championship","id":"216","oid":"216","ovid":"1034","order":5,"hasData":1},"1008":{"title":"Investec Champions Cup","uri":"european-champions-cup","id":"110","oid":"242","ovid":"1008","order":6,"hasData":1},"1026":{"title":"Challenge Cup","uri":"challenge-cup","id":"118","oid":"243","ovid":"1026","order":7,"hasData":1},"1020":{"title":"Super Rugby Pacific","uri":"super-rugby","id":"104","oid":"205","ovid":"1020","order":8,"hasData":1},"1011":{"title":"PREM Rugby","uri":"premiership","id":"101","oid":"201","ovid":"1011","order":9,"hasData":1},"1068":{"title":"United Rugby Championship","uri":"united-rugby-championship","id":"138","oid":"204","ovid":"1068","order":10,"hasData":1},"1002":{"title":"TOP 14","uri":"top-14","id":"102","oid":"203","ovid":"1002","order":11,"hasData":1},"1013":{"title":"Pro D2","uri":"pro-d2","id":"211","oid":"211","ovid":"1013","order":12,"hasData":1},"2062":{"title":"International","uri":"internationals","id":"107","oid":"3","ovid":"2062","order":13,"hasData":1},"2066":{"title":"Women's Internationals","uri":"womens-internationals","id":"274","oid":"274","ovid":"2066","order":14,"hasData":1},"1095":{"title":"PWR","uri":"premiership-womens-rugby","id":"127","oid":"340","ovid":"1095","order":17,"hasData":1},"1174":{"title":"Major League Rugby","uri":"major-league-rugby","id":"131","oid":"151","ovid":"1174","order":18,"hasData":1},"1106":{"title":"Women's Six Nations","uri":"womens-six-nations","id":"125","oid":"248","ovid":"1106","order":19,"hasData":1},"1055":{"title":"Six Nations","uri":"six-nations","id":"108","oid":"209","ovid":"1055","order":20,"hasData":1},"1062":{"title":"U20 Six Nations","uri":"u20-six-nations","id":"217","oid":"217","ovid":"1062","order":21,"hasData":1},"2070":{"title":"Pacific Four Series","uri":"pacific-four-series","id":"120","oid":"120","ovid":"2070","order":22,"hasData":1},"1001":{"title":"Hilux NPC","uri":"bunnings-npc","id":"105","oid":"208","ovid":"1001","order":23,"hasData":1},"1039":{"title":"Currie Cup","uri":"currie-cup","id":"106","oid":"207","ovid":"1039","order":24,"hasData":1},"1171":{"title":"Women's Rugby World Cup","uri":"womens-rugby-world-cup","id":"126","oid":"249","ovid":"1171","order":25,"hasData":1},"1119":{"title":"Rugby Europe Championship","uri":"rugby-europe-championship","id":"269","oid":"269","ovid":"1119","order":27,"hasData":1},"1535":{"title":"British & Irish Lions 2025","uri":"british-irish-lions","id":"113","oid":"221","ovid":"1535","order":28,"hasData":1},"1053":{"title":"The Rugby Championship","uri":"the-rugby-championship","id":"109","oid":"214","ovid":"1053","order":29,"hasData":1},"1260":{"title":"Pacific Nations Cup","uri":"pacific-nations-cup","id":"219","oid":"219","ovid":"1260","order":30,"hasData":1},"2151":{"title":"WXV Global Series","uri":"wxv","id":"144","oid":"144","ovid":"2151","order":33,"hasData":1},"2096":{"title":"WXV 2","uri":"wxv-2","id":"863","oid":"863","ovid":"2096","order":36,"hasData":1},"2097":{"title":"WXV 3","uri":"wxv-3","id":"864","oid":"864","ovid":"2097","order":37,"hasData":1},"1297":{"title":"Premiership Cup","uri":"premiership-cup","id":"116","oid":"116","ovid":"1297","order":39,"hasData":1}}

Ireland v South Africa: Rivalry with a unique edge

CAPE TOWN, SOUTH AFRICA - JUNE 11: CJ Stander of Ireland receives a red card during the 1st Castle Lager Incoming Series Test match between South Africa and Ireland at DHL Newlands Stadium on June 11, 2016 in Cape Town, South Africa. (Photo by Luke Walker/Gallo Images/Getty Images)

OPINION: Jan de Koning dips back into the archives to revisit some of the classic clashes of the past, as Ireland prepare to host South Africa in Dublin on Saturday.

ADVERTISEMENT

There is the little matter of the final Nations Championship league positions to be decided.

However, when Ireland host South Africa in Dublin on Saturday, it will be the resumption of a rivalry that has produced classic and sometimes brutal clashes.

Dating back to 1906, the Springboks versus Ireland rivalry has been a series of fierce tactical and physical clashes, sometimes spilling over into brutal thuggery – as happened in 1998.

South Africa relies on monumental set-piece dominance, suffocating rush defence, and late-game forward depth to physically break the opposition.

Ireland counters with ultra-organised multi-phase attack, deceptive wrap-around plays, and elite breakdown efficiency designed to pull heavy forward packs out of position.

ADVERTISEMENT

Then there is the cross-pollination of coaching ideas.

World Cup-winning former Springbok coach Jacques Nienaber joined Leinster after the 2023 World Cup, while there are two Irish assistant coaches currently in the Springbok camp: former Ireland internationals Jerry Flannery and Felix Jones, alongside Irish performance analyst Paddy Sullivan.

In 31 official Test matches played since 1906, South Africa leads the all-time head-to-head series with 20 wins, Ireland has 10 wins, and one match ended in a draw.

Unlike the lopsided early eras where South Africa dominated, the last decade has been a virtual deadlock.

ADVERTISEMENT

Ireland went on a strong run – winning in Cape Town (2016), Dublin (2017, 2022), Paris (2023), and Durban (2024) – while South Africa answered with dramatic series clinchers (2016), a bruising win in Pretoria (2024), and a statement victory in Dublin (2025).

The other big contrast is between Ireland’s dominance in bilateral Tests and World Cup pool stages, versus South Africa’s unmatched pedigree in knockout rugby (winning back-to-back titles in 2019 and 2023 despite losing to Ireland in the 2023 pool stage).

Some of the most memorable matches between Ireland and South Africa feature historic firsts, World Cup stakes, and tight modern battles.

Ireland’s 2016 win in Cape Town and 2023 World Cup pool win in Paris stand out alongside South Africa’s road wins in Dublin.

South Africa is the only major Southern Hemisphere team over which Ireland has not achieved a series victory, although in 2024 the two sides shared a series in South Africa one-all.

The 1906 tour was instrumental in uniting the country and establishing South Africa as a global rugby powerhouse.

Below are five classic clashes in the last 120 years …

1998 – Loftus Versfeld, Pretoria: South Africa 33-0 Ireland

The year 1998 was not good for South African and Irish relationships.

Most pundits would focus on the Springboks’ 37-13 win over Ireland in Bloemfontein, or their 27-13 win at Lansdowne Road in Dublin that November.

For me, it was Loftus Versfeld, June 20 – undoubtedly one of the most brutal, the dirtiest and most ill-tempered games I ever watched live.

In 1998, Ireland toured the Republic with a young and inexperienced side, facing a Springbok team who were on a six-match winning streak and fresh off a European tour in 1997 where records were shattered.

While some decent rugby was played in Bloemfontein, tempers were already simmering.

In Pretoria, a week later, it boiled over, as the outclassed Irish let their frustrations get the better of them.

Current Bok coach Rassie Erasmus will remember that game best for the fisticuffs, including a couple of neat uppercuts from Trevor Brennan, later banned for life for attacking a fan at a game.

Dion O’Cuinneagain, who had captained South Africa at both schoolboy and Sevens level before he switched allegiances, made his senior international debut for Ireland in Bloemfontein.

Paul Wallace, Keith Wood and Peter Clohessy were other roughies in the tour squad. The drama at Loftus was simmering from the outset, but boiled over after an off-the-ball incident with Springbok Captain Gary Teichmann set off a series of punch-ups and off-the-ball incidents.

Tensions continued to simmer on the field, fueled by ever-more robust tackling and fiercely contested set-pieces.

Try as he might, French referee Joël Dumé lost control of the game as he found himself constantly intervening in punch-ups all over the field.

2004 – Lansdowne Road, Dublin: Ireland 17-12 South Africa

This game will be forever remembered for the infamous Paul Honiss ‘speak to your team’ moment.

The game’s only try was scored in controversial circumstances by Irish flyhalf Ronan O’Gara.

In the 21st minute, the New Zealand referee, Honiss, awarded Ireland a penalty inside the South African 22 and told John Smit to go and talk to his players regarding their repeated infringements at the breakdown.

Honiss later claimed that he never intended to stop the match, even though he had called ‘time off’.

“I inadvertently had a discussion with John Smit, to say: ‘Look mate, you can’t keep giving penalties away’, and I had no intention of basically stopping the game. It was a quick message to John,” he told Aaron Goile of stuff.co.nz.

“Unbeknownst to me, behind my back, he was calling his team together. My assistant referee gave me no indication [about what Smit was doing], and I was walking back to the mark, and I even said to the TMO I’m going to restart the game.

“The upshot was that from that particular decision, Ireland scored a try which, on reflection, was wrong. And I took that, myself, as being my mistake.”

He said the Bok captain, Smit, should have asked for ‘permission’ to speak to his team, despite having already been told to do so.

2016 – Newlands, Cape Town: South Africa 20–26 Ireland

This is one of those famous firsts.

Ireland secured their first-ever Test victory on South African soil with a 26–20 win over the Springboks at Newlands Stadium on June 11, playing with 14 men for nearly an hour after CJ Stander was sent off for a mid-air collision with Pat Lambie.

Lock Lood de Jager was yellow-carded in the 11th minute, and Ireland capitalised immediately when fullback Jared Payne crossed for the opening try, converted by Paddy Jackson.

In the 23rd minute, Irish flanker CJ Stander jumped to charge down a kick from the Springbok flyhalf, Lambie, and collided mid-air with his hip. Lambie was knocked unconscious and forced off, while referee Mathieu Raynal issued Stander a straight red card.

The story continues below…

South Africa took a 13–10 lead into the final 10 minutes of the first half after Lwazi Mvovo scored a try on the corner, during which Irish centre Robbie Henshaw was also yellow-carded for a high tackle on replacement flyhalf Elton Jantjies.

Despite temporarily playing with 13 men, Ireland levelled the match at 13–all before half-time via a Paddy Jackson drop-goal.

Just three minutes after the restart, Ireland reclaimed the lead when Jared Payne offloaded to scrumhalf Conor Murray for a converted try.

Jackson stretched the lead to 23–13 with a 68th-minute penalty before Pieter-Steph du Toit intercepted a Jackson pass a minute later to bring South Africa within three points.

Jackson added a final penalty in the 77th minute, and Ireland’s defence bundled JP Pietersen into touch late on to seal the historic result.

2017 – Lansdowne Road, Dublin: Ireland 38–3 South Africa

The match took a turn for the worse from the outset, when prop Coenie Oosthuizen twisted his knee and was forced off.

Ireland took immediate control through their set-piece and aerial kicking, with Man of the Match Johnny Sexton slotting three penalties in the opening 21 minutes for a 9–0 lead.

In the 25th minute, Sexton hoisted a cross-field kick to the right wing where Andrew Conway leaped over Dillyn Leyds to gather and score, sending Ireland into half-time with a 14–0 cushion.

Elton Jantjies put South Africa on the board with a 44th-minute penalty, and Sexton replied with a fourth penalty in the 57th minute to make it 17–3. With the match bogged down in errors, young wing Jacob Stockdale sparked the crowd by dumping Dillyn Leyds backwards in a big tackle.

Ireland cut loose in the closing stages against a tiring Springbok defence; replacement flank Rhys Ruddock collected a clever pass from Robbie Henshaw five metres out and powered over, before replacement hooker Rob Herring grounded the ball at the back of a dominant Irish line-out maul and debutant wing Darren Sweetnam helped spark a sweeping counterattack that Jacob Stockdale finished in the corner to seal a record 35-point winning margin.

Although Allister Coetzee’s tenure as Springbok coach ended on 2 February 2018, this result was arguably the final nail in the proverbial coffin.

Coetzee’s 21-month stint (April 2016 – February 2018) was marked by a 44 percent win rate (11 wins, 12 losses, and two draws in 25 Tests) and a drop in South Africa’s World Rugby ranking from third to sixth, allowing for the return of Rassie Erasmus.

2023 – Stade de France, Paris: Ireland 13-8 South Africa

In a crucial World Cup Pool B match, world No.1 Ireland edged the defending champion Boks 13–8 in a classic match that had the Irish fans belting out the famous Cranberries song Zombie.

The official estimate was that there were roughly 35,000 Irish fans in Paris for the match.

It was a statement victory from Ireland, with Johnny Sexton flawless off the tee and Manie Libbok landing one from five.

However, it was the post-match arrogance (confidence?) of the Irish that riled up the Boks, with Eben Etzebeth famously recalling he was told by the Irish that they would see South Africa in the Final.

SA reached the Final.

Ireland did not.

Ireland did win a classic in the iconic Paris venue on that balmy September evening, one of the most pulsating and enthralling matches for years.

It was a contest where you dared not blink for fear of missing a game-changing moment.

That kind of intensity I again experienced in three one-point play-off wins by the Boks on their way to a fourth World Cup title.

* On to Dublin we march, for Saturday’s much-anticipated Nations Championship face-off!

Dubai SVNS

The HSBC SVNS series heads to Dubai on 28-29 November! Get your tickets now 

Join free

How England Could Turn an All Blacks Upset Into a Crisis | ARP Extra

Did Wales Expose a Deeper All Blacks Problem? | Aotearoa Rugby Pod | Episode 40

Wallabies in freefall! Wales shock the world | KOKO Show | Nov 17th |

Portugal v Samoa | Nations Cup 2026 | Round 5 | Match Highlights

Romania v USA | Nations Cup 2026 | Round 5 | Match Highlights

Spain v Chile | Nations Cup 2026 | Round 5 | Match Highlights

Zimbabwe v Uruguay | Nations Cup 2026 | Round 5 | Match Highlights

Georgia v Tonga | Nations Cup 2026 | Round 5 | Match Highlights

Write A Comment