Player ratings: South Africa
OPINION: The Springboks suffered a narrow 17-20 defeat to Ireland in Dublin on Saturday, losing a bruising Nations Championship encounter that was decided by fine margins.
South Africa had their opportunities to take control of the contest but were unable to make them count, with handling errors and costly penalties proving particularly damaging.
There were some impressive individual performances, particularly in the forwards, but others will be disappointed with their contribution as the Boks fell short against Andy Farrell’s side.
Here is how we rated the Springboks:
15 Damian Willemse – 4/10
Missed the tackle that allowed Ireland to score their first try and tapped the ball, which ultimately led to the hosts’ second. It was an error-strewn start to his evening, and he was forced off in the 25th minute, making way for Canan Moodie.
14 Kurt-Lee Arendse – 5/10
Marshalled his tramline well and produced a brilliant break that sent Moodie racing towards the tryline. However, Arendse also lost possession with the tryline in front of him. South Africa had a penalty advantage at the time and could have made the opportunity count.
13 Jesse Kriel – 5/10
Often drifted out wide to assist defensively, with his performance highlighted by some important cover tackles. However, he dropped a pass as South Africa launched a late attack in search of a potential match-winning score.
12 Damian de Allende – 6/10
Stood strong in the physical battle and was immense defensively. He also played an important role in Malcolm Marx’s try, making him one of South Africa’s best performers in the backline.
11 Ethan Hooker – 6/10
Once again showed his strength in the aerial battle, competing fiercely for possession and winning half of his contests. His defensive work was arguably his strongest contribution, while he moved to inside centre late in the match.
10 Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu – 4/10
Kicked South Africa’s first penalty to get the scoreboard moving. He did little wrong in the first half but also struggled to make a significant attacking impact. He lost possession midway through the second half and had difficulties dealing with Ireland’s high balls. It was not his best outing in the green and gold, although he produced a crucial defensive moment by holding up Dan Sheehan over the tryline.
9 Morne van den Berg – 6/10
Produced a try-saving tackle in the fifth minute but often opted to kick from behind the ruck rather than release his backline. He made a beautiful break shortly after half-time, putting South Africa on the front foot and helping create the opportunity for Moodie’s try. He was also regularly trusted to kick for touch instead of Feinberg-Mngomezulu.
8 Cameron Hanekom – 7/10
Made a massive defensive contribution, helping prevent Ireland from scoring their second try, and relentlessly hunted down Sam Prendergast. He made a strong impact after coming on in the second half to replace Du Toit, with South Africa threatening to score late in the game.
7 Pieter-Steph du Toit – 7/10
Had plenty of defensive work to do in the first half, with little possession to work with. As ever, he was immense in the tackle, making 13 before leaving the field for a head injury assessment. He was replaced by Hanekom.
6 Siya Kolisi – 5/10
Was penalised for holding on after South Africa’s first lineout, putting the Boks under pressure inside their own 22. He departed early in the second half following a fairly quiet first-half performance.
5 Franco Mostert – 5/10
Conceded an early penalty for sealing off at the breakdown after a good carry. He and Du Toit were South Africa’s leading tacklers, underlining the amount of defensive work required from the forwards.
4 Eben Etzebeth – 6/10
Had a relatively quiet first half but produced a brilliant take under a Van den Berg kick and landed some massive hits in the physical exchanges.
3 Wilco Louw – 6/10
Helped South Africa gain a psychological advantage at scrum time and won a penalty at the second scrum keeping the Boks in the game in the first half. He was penalised early in the second half and replaced seven minutes later.
2 Malcolm Marx – 6/10
South Africa led the lineout statistics, with Marx’s throwing providing a solid platform. He scored his 33rd Test try after sustained pressure from the Boks, reducing Ireland’s led to three points at 20-17. He left the field after an hour.
1 Ox Nche – 4/10
Produced a brilliant scrum alongside Marx and Louw five minutes before half-time, helping create the platform for Van den Berg’s try and extending South Africa’s led to close the gap to 10-17 at the break. But overall, he didn’t do his title of the best loosehead in the business any justice.
Replacements
16 Jan-Hendrik Wessels – 3/10
Replaced Marx after an hour but struggled with his first two lineout throws, allowing Ireland to apply pressure at a crucial stage with the Boks trailing 17-20. He also made a costly error by playing the ball while offside with three minutes remaining.
17 Gerhard Steenekamp – 4/10
Came on in the 47th minute as South Africa looked to maintain their dominance in the scrum. Didn’t enforce himself in the scrums.
18 Thomas du Toit – 4/10
Also entered the game in the 47th minute and stepped up when South Africa needed a big scrum with 13 minutes remaining. Added a few strong carries but also conceded a vital penalty.
19 Lood de Jager – 6/10
Came on in the 47th minute and appeared more comfortable with Etzebeth alongside him in the second row. His experience brought some calm to a rattled side.
20 Paul de Villiers – 5/10
Made an immediate impact, turning over possession as Ireland attacked in front of the Bok posts. Produced another brilliant steal on the floor inside South Africa’s 22.
21 Marco van Staden – 2/10
Thrown straight into the action as Ireland attacked and defended with real intensity. He became involved in a major confrontation after diving headfirst into a ruck to clear out, earning a yellow card at the same time Ireland captain Caelan Doris was also sent off. The yellow was upgraded to red, which means he will miss the finals weekend at Twickenham next weekend.
22 Grant Williams – 3/10
Came on late in the second half, replacing Moodie and moving to the wing. Was penalised for being offside just minutes later (although the penalty was cancelled) but didn’t do much.
23 Canan Moodie – 5/10
He blew hot and cold after replacing Willemse in the 25th minute and came close to scoring five minutes later. His chip ahead helped create a scoring opportunity for South Africa, but he later conceded a soft penalty after being caught offside following a Van den Berg kick. Ireland kicked to the corner and scored their third try on the stroke of half-time. Moodie thought he had scored after the break, but his effort was ruled out because he had been in touch. He also had the ball stripped from his grasp after winning possession from a long lineout throw.

Watch Hemispheres collide as North faces South in the Nations Championship. Live matches, replays and highlights free on RugbyPass TV here
(*USA only)