Rennie will bring clarity... but All Blacks are pressed for time

OPINION: Dave Rennie faces a number of significant challenges in rebuilding the All Blacks ahead of the all-important series against the Springboks this August.

New Zealand Rugby has been in free-fall for the past couple of months.

Chaos and uncertainty defined Scott Robertson’s tenure as head coach, yet there have been more questions than answers since his departure in January.

The New Zealand media reports that the search for a new CEO is ongoing, while other long-serving members of the organisation, such as head of performance Nic Gill, have opted to leave the All Blacks.

This past Monday, Springbok attack coach Tony Brown – who represented the All Blacks and coached in New Zealand for many years – questioned New Zealand Rugby’s decision to fire Robertson at this stage.

“It was surprising that New Zealand Rugby made a change,” Brown offered. “They obviously felt it was required.

“Whoever gets the [head coach] job, I guarantee the All Blacks will be very good this year.”

Brown made it clear that the Boks won’t underestimate the All Blacks ahead of the inaugural Greatest Rivalry tour in South Africa this August.

At the same time, he appeared to question the timing of the decision, and infer that the next All Blacks coach would have a mountain to climb – in the lead-up to the series in South Africa and ahead of the 2027 World Cup.

On Wednesday, the NZR confirmed that Dave Rennie had got the job.

The story continues below…

Rennie was preferred over Jamie Joseph due to his Test experience with Australia between 2020 and 2022 – even though he achieved a disappointing 38% win-record.

Rennie’s management style was endorsed by a host of former players, and overall, his clarity and messaging has been described as a strength.

By contrast, Robertson was often criticised for a lack of clarity, and by the end, his players had lost faith in him and his vision for the All Blacks.

Rennie has achieved a great deal in the game, and South African fans may remember how well his Chiefs side fared on tours to the Republic in the days of the old Super Rugby competition.

The Chiefs won back-to-back titles in 2012 and 2013, and while there were a lot of talented players in that squad, Rennie prioritised team culture and hard work.

The story continues below…

During his short stint with the Wallabies, he implemented a much-needed physical element, and the team went on to win three out of four matches against the Boks – albeit on Australian soil.

A few parallels can be drawn between the appointment of Rennie at the All Blacks and that of Rassie Erasmus at the Boks in 2018.

Like Erasmus, Rennie has the technical knowledge to improve the team as well as the emotional intelligence to connect with the players.

What he doesn’t have, of course, is a lot of time.

There’s plenty of optimism in New Zealand at present, but Rennie himself summed the situation up when he said, “We’ve got a lot of work to do”.

Rennie is currently coaching the Kobe Steelers in Japan and won’t return to New Zealand permanently until his club contract expires in June.

He intends to juggle both positions in the interim, but having spent some time with the Bok coaches this week and seeing how hard they work – even during the “off-season”– I wonder how ready the All Blacks will be for the start of the 2026 schedule.

As is the case with the CEO position, the identity of the new coaching staff is yet to be confirmed. Rennie will have the benefit of appointing his own lieutenants and, presumably, his own skipper.

At a glance, the first fixture of the year against France appears daunting, as Les Bleus have been the form side in the Six Nations.

That said, reports from Europe suggest that France may send a weakened side to New Zealand for the Nations Championship opener.

It’s possible that the All Blacks will win all three Tests against France, Italy and Ireland this July, and take some momentum into the series against the Boks.

But the demands of that series in South Africa will be significant – and it’s worth noting that the Boks have been building towards those Tests for some time.

Depth may be decisive in a brutally physical Test series that spans three weeks in South Africa. Immediately after the third Test, the teams will fly to Baltimore, USA, for the decider.

Erasmus has already stated that the Boks will need 40 or more players to cope with the demands of that series – and it’s highly unlikely that the same line-up will feature every week.

The All Blacks, of course, will have to navigate the preceding tour matches against the Stormers, Sharks, Bulls and Lions before tackling the Boks in the Tests.

The tourists will go into the matches against the franchises as favourites, but the nature of those fixtures may take a toll on the New Zealanders, and one or two big names may succumb to injury.

So much has been said about the current state of Super Rugby, and how New Zealand and Australia are missing the physicality edge of the South Africans.

Will the Super Rugby tournament prepare the All Blacks for the unique challenge of facing the Boks in four consecutive Tests later this year?

The July Tests will demand a step up, but it remains to be seen who will turn out for France, and whether Italy and Ireland will be up for a scrap at the end of a long northern-hemisphere season.

Rennie may be the right man for the job, but the New Zealand rugby community holds the All Blacks to the highest standard, and expectations will be sky-high.

Winning the series against the Boks would serve as a monumental statement, but given all that has transpired in recent months on the field and in the boardroom, an All Blacks revival may take more than a few months.