Do Not Sell My Personal Information
RugbyPass Match Centre
Scores
Sorry there are no live games.
See what's coming up.
Canterbury CAN Taranaki TAR Sat
19 Sep
6:15am SAST
Bay of Plenty BAY Southland SOU Sat
19 Sep
9:00am SAST
Manawatu MAN Otago OTA Sun
20 Sep
4:00am SAST
Hawke's Bay HAW Counties COU Sun
20 Sep
4:00am SAST
Auckland AUC Wellington WEL Sun
20 Sep
6:15am SAST
Wellington WEL Bay of Plenty BAY Fri
25 Sep
9:00am SAST
Tasman TAS Waikato WAI Sat
26 Sep
4:00am SAST
Southland SOU North Harbour HAR Sat
26 Sep
6:15am SAST
Hawke's Bay HAW Canterbury CAN Sat
26 Sep
9:00am SAST
Auckland AUC Manawatu MAN Sun
27 Sep
3:00am SAST
Taranaki TAR Otago OTA Sun
27 Sep
3:00am SAST
Counties COU Northland NOR Sun
27 Sep
5:15am SAST
Bay of Plenty BAY Auckland AUC Fri
2 Oct
8:00am SAST
Counties COU Manawatu MAN Sat
3 Oct
3:00am SAST
Northland NOR Taranaki TAR Sat
3 Oct
5:15am SAST
Canterbury CAN Wellington WEL Sat
3 Oct
8:00am SAST
Southland SOU Waikato WAI Sun
4 Oct
3:00am SAST
North Harbour HAR Tasman TAS Sun
4 Oct
3:00am SAST
Otago OTA Hawke's Bay HAW Sun
4 Oct
5:15am SAST
Manawatu MAN Canterbury CAN Fri
9 Oct
8:00am SAST
Taranaki TAR Auckland AUC Sat
10 Oct
3:00am SAST
Wellington WEL Otago OTA Sat
10 Oct
5:15am SAST
Waikato WAI Counties COU Sat
10 Oct
8:00am SAST
Tasman TAS Bay of Plenty BAY Sun
11 Oct
3:00am SAST
North Harbour HAR Hawke's Bay HAW Sun
11 Oct
3:00am SAST
Northland NOR Southland SOU Sun
11 Oct
5:15am SAST
Hawke's Bay HAW Northland NOR Fri
16 Oct
8:00am SAST
Manawatu MAN Bay of Plenty BAY Sat
17 Oct
3:00am SAST
Auckland AUC Tasman TAS Sat
17 Oct
5:15am SAST
Southland SOU Taranaki TAR Sat
17 Oct
8:00am SAST
Canterbury CAN Waikato WAI Sun
18 Oct
3:00am SAST
Otago OTA Counties COU Sun
18 Oct
3:00am SAST
Wellington WEL North Harbour HAR Sun
18 Oct
5:15am SAST
Otago OTA Northland NOR Fri
23 Oct
8:00am SAST
Bay of Plenty BAY Canterbury CAN Sat
24 Oct
3:00am SAST
Hawke's Bay HAW Manawatu MAN Sat
24 Oct
5:15am SAST
North Harbour HAR Auckland AUC Sat
24 Oct
8:00am SAST
Tasman TAS Southland SOU Sun
25 Oct
3:00am SAST
Counties COU Wellington WEL Sun
25 Oct
3:00am SAST
Waikato WAI Taranaki TAR Sun
25 Oct
5:15am SAST
Canterbury CAN Otago OTA Fri
30 Oct
8:00am SAST
Wellington WEL Tasman TAS Sat
31 Oct
3:00am SAST
Northland NOR North Harbour HAR Sat
31 Oct
5:15am SAST
Auckland AUC Waikato WAI Sat
31 Oct
8:00am SAST
Bay of Plenty BAY Hawke's Bay HAW Sun
1 Nov
3:00am SAST
Manawatu MAN Southland SOU Sun
1 Nov
3:00am SAST
Taranaki TAR Counties COU Sun
1 Nov
5:15am SAST
Southland SOU Otago OTA Fri
6 Nov
8:00am SAST
Auckland AUC Northland NOR Sat
7 Nov
3:00am SAST
North Harbour HAR Counties COU Sat
7 Nov
5:15am SAST
Tasman TAS Canterbury CAN Sat
7 Nov
8:00am SAST
Waikato WAI Bay of Plenty BAY Sun
8 Nov
3:00am SAST
Hawke's Bay HAW Wellington WEL Sun
8 Nov
3:00am SAST
Manawatu MAN Taranaki TAR Sun
8 Nov
5:15am SAST
Fri 24 May 2019 | 08:57

Law discussion: 'We wuz robbed'

Law discussion: 'We wuz robbed'
Fri 24 May 2019 | 08:57
Law discussion: 'We wuz robbed'
SHARE

SUPER RUGBY SPOTLIGHT: @rugby365com law guru Paul Dobson gets his teeth into the controversies at Newlands last week and claims the ‘We wuz robbed’.

ADVERTISEMENT

Or wuz we?

“We wuz robbed” was the mournful complaint of Joe Jacobs, the boxer’s manager when his fighter Max Schmeling lost to Jack Sharkey in 1930. It is a cry that has echoed round the sporting world for the 89 years that followed, most recently from the city of Christchurch on New Zealand’s South Island.

It follows a decision about a forward pass in the match at Newlands between the champion Crusaders and the home side, the Stormers.

We have taken three incidents from the match for a law discussion. It is for the reader to decide who, if anybody, wuz robbed.

https://youtu.be/tnVoV-_9VGU

1. 73/74 minutes: that pass

The score is 19-16 to the Crusaders with time running out. The Crusaders have the ball and are going right. On the half-way line, Braydon Ennor passes to right wing Sevu Reece. Reece sprints ahead and then, hemmed in, kicks. Damian Willemse of the Stormers is leading the race for the ball but it breaks to the right in in-goal. Reece gets the kind bounce and scores. The try is awarded, but…

The TMO suggested a look at the pass. The referee consults the TMO. The TMO first says: “I am going to show you a forward pass.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Then, after a couple of replays, the TMO Marius Jonker says: “We have a forward pass, it is clear and compelling evidence of a forward pass”.

The try is cancelled and instead the Stormers put the ball into a scrum on the half-way line.

There has been debate about the pass. The ball leaves Ennor’s hands on the half-way line. Reece catches it about a metre over the half-way line. Does that make it a forward pass?

Not necessarily.

ADVERTISEMENT

In the Law book, the forward pass is referred to as a throw forward.

DEFINITION
Throw forward: When a player throws or passes the ball forward, i.e. if the arms of the player passing the ball move forward.

It’s not about where the ball is caught. That can be affected by the momentum, of the player passing the ball. It’s easy to see the effect of momentum. Drive down a street and when you get opposite a pole throw a ball out of the window straight at the pole. The ball will land well ahead of the pole. (There are other even more telling tests that you can do.)

DEFINITION
Forward: Towards the opposition’s dead-ball line.

It’s about the movement of Ennor’s arms in the act of passing. Do his arms move forward?

If they do not, the pass was not forward.
If they do move forward, the pass was forward.

clear and compelling?

It is interesting that forward passes and knock-ons, such basic bits of rugby law, are not all that easy to decide and are often wrongly treated, sometimes one feels for the look of the thing.

2. 45 minutes: and this pass

Early in the second half, with the score 12-10 to the Crusaders, Joshua Stander of the Stormers kicks downfield. Just inside his half, Sevu Reece of the Crusaders catches the ball and passes to David Havili. Havili runs ahead and is stopped and held upright by two Stormers, Pieter-Steph du Toit and Cobus Wiese. George Bower of the Crusaders joins in but the referee calls “Tackle!”. Havili is released and the ball comes back to Bryn Hall. The Crusaders go left as Hall passes to Ethan Blackadder who passes to Richie Mo’unga. Mo’unga holds his pass till Codie Taylor is through a gap. He passes to the hooker who charges downfield. Confronted by Damian Willemse (15), Taylor passes to Braydon Ennor who races down the left and scores. Mo’unga converts.

The interesting pass to look at is Mo’unga’s to Taylor.

Are Mo’unga’s arms and hands parallel to the goal-lines or inclined towards the Crusaders’ goal-line or are they more inclinded towards the Stornmers’ goial-line?

If the arms and hands are across the parallel line and inclined towards the Stormers’ goal-line, the pass is forward, but undetected.

3. 27/28 minutes: playing the man without the ball.

The Stormers are penalised at a tackle. Richie Mo’unga of the Crusaders kicks out for a five-metre lineout. Codie Taylor, the Crusaders’ hooker, gets ready to throw in and eventually six Crusaders line up in the lineout with six Stormers to oppose them. Herschel Jantjies, the Stormers’ scrumhalf, takes up a position in the tramlines as Taylor’s immediate opponent.

Taylor throws in to Scott Barrett who catches the ball at No.2 in the lineout. The Crusaders form a maul, spin it round and Todd goes over for a try, which is awarded.

But whoa! Look what happens to Jantjies. He does not join in the maul but stays in position to guard the tramlines. Taylor’s goes up behind Jantjies and gives the scrumhalf a hefty push in the back that sends him sprawling some five metres from his station. Then Todd has a free run around the front of the lineout.

Law 9.14 A player must not tackle an opponent who is not in possession of the ball.

Instead of scoring a try, the Crusaders should have been penalised.

By Paul Dobson
@rugby365com

PV: 2054
ADVERTISEMENT
Law discussion: 'We wuz robbed' | Rugby365