Schools rankings: A call to level the playing field
Another thrilling weekend of schoolboy rugby has passed, showcasing once again the incredible talent emerging from the world champions, South Africa.
The highlight of the weekend was undoubtedly the KwaZulu-Natal derby between two top-10 powerhouses: DHS and Westville. In a closely contested match, Westville narrowly came out on top with a 33–28 victory.
Meanwhile, the two Paarl giants once again proved why they are unquestionably the top two rugby schools in the country. Paarl Boys’ High (Boishaai) secured a convincing 36–26 win over Paul Roos, while Paarl Gimnasium dominated HTS Drostdy with a staggering 92–12 victory.
These one-sided results raise an important question: Is South African schoolboy rugby as healthy as we think it is? When just five elite schools consistently dominate and overwhelm the rest, is the game truly thriving? Many boys lose interest in playing after such heavy defeats. Has the sport at some schools become overly professional, and are these institutions perhaps “stripping” other schools of their talent?
It may be time for SA Rugby to consider implementing regulations to level the playing field. One suggestion is to restrict schools to recruiting players only from within their own provinces. Without such measures, smaller provincial unions could see their Craven Week sides fade into irrelevance.
A growing concern is that some Gauteng schools, for instance, are unable to accommodate local students while their hostels are filled with learners from other provinces.
Should this be allowed to continue?
The story continues below…
Perhaps SA Rugby, in collaboration with the Department of Education and the state, should adopt a policy similar to that of New Zealand Rugby.
There, students can only move schools across provincial borders if their parents relocate as well. This has helped distribute talent more evenly across the country and maintained a competitive balance.
We don’t want to lose the future Pieter Steph du Toits and late developers at a small school to stop playing rugby because of humiliating scores like above.
A warm welcome to the new entrants in our top 50: Milnerton and Wesvalia. No ranking system is perfect, but we do our best, and we always value your feedback in the comments.
The next rankings will be released on June 1st. As the legendary Oom Zanberg Jansen used to say: “Nag, ou grote.”
Picture credit: @PaarlBoysHighSchool
