Is this the end for SANZAAR showpiece?
#COVID-19: Super Rugby has confronted numerous problems during its 25 years, but experts warn the coronavirus pandemic may prove a knockout blow for the Southern Hemisphere’s premier franchise competition.
With 15 teams in five countries straddling 16 time zones from Buenos Aires and Cape Town to Sydney and Christchurch it has long been criticised as unwieldy, expensive to run and exhausting for elite players.
Now virus-related travel bans have put the competition in limbo, leaving administrators scrambling to set up locally-based alternatives that do not require international travel.
While officials say Super Rugby is on hold “for the foreseeable future”, in reality, they are preparing for the season to be scrapped.
SANZAAR admitted that would place the governing body and its constituent unions “in a precarious position”, as broadcasters have paid huge sums for the rights to cover the game.
“Without that revenue, without the ability to be playing in front of stadiums that have crowds, it all does have a direct impact on the bottom line,” SANZAAR chief executive Andy Marinos told Newshub.
“That’s something I know the national unions are dealing with all of their clubs and then indirectly with all their governments.”
Short-term plans are focused on staging local derbies in New Zealand, Australia and South Africa, with Japan’s Sunwolves potentially part of the Australian competition and the Jaguares of Argentina based in Africa.
However, that may not satisfy broadcasters.
New Zealand’s Sky Network Television noted in a market update this week that “the company has options to recover some costs associated with sports content rights”.
(Continue reading below…)
Broadcast cash ‘spent already’
Australia-based sports consultancy firm Global Media & Sports (GMS) said SANZAAR’s members were in no position to pay back tens of millions of dollars in broadcasting revenues.
“I doubt any of the unions could afford to do that, I’d wager that most of that money has been spent already, or at least allocated,” GMS managing director Colin Smith told AFP.
Given Super Rugby’s myriad structural problems, Smith said, the virus-enforced shutdown would raise questions about its future, with the makeshift local derby matches potentially forming the nucleus of new national competitions.
“It’s been very, very expensive and there’s an argument for the unions to say ‘Is this something we should continue with, can we afford it?’,” he said.
“It goes to the future of the competition.”
Super Rugby has its foundation in humble beginnings long before the professional era – dating back to the six-team South Pacific Championship in 1986.
After the demise of the South Pacific Championship, with no tournament played in 1991, the competition was relaunched as the Super Six in 1992 – consisted of three provincial teams from New Zealand (Auckland, Canterbury, Wellington), along with two Australian state teams (Queensland and New South Wales) and also the Fiji national team.
Then followed the Super 10 with the introduction of South Africa in 1993. The inaugural competition featured Waikato, Auckland, Otago and North Harbour (New Zealand); Natal, Transvaal and Northern Transvaal (South Africa); Queensland and New South Wales (Australia) and Western Samoa (Pacific Tri-Nations winner).
Then followed the professional (SANZA[A]R era – which began with 12 teams in 1996.
However, the format has undergone almost constant tinkering in the past decade – 14 teams, 15 teams and finally 18 teams, testing the loyalty of fans.
Over-ambitious expansion plans have been followed by the painful axing of Australia’s Western Force, the Cheetahs and Southern Kings in South Africa, as well as the Sunwolves at the end of the current (2020) season.
The Cheetahs and Kings both joined Europe’s Pro14 competition and there has been persistent speculation all of South Africa’s teams could ditch Super Rugby for a more lucrative and time zone-friendly switch to the Northern Hemisphere.
In Australia, the game has been flatlining in the face of keen competition from other sports, notably Rugby League and Australian Rules, after years of poor on-field performances.
Rugby Australia has suspended negotiations on a new broadcast deal due to the virus crisis, with reports it had received little interest anyway.
“This couldn’t have come at a worse time for them,” Smith said.
Despite the issues, New Zealand Rugby Chief Executive Mark Robinson insisted Super Rugby was viable in the long term.
“We’re a world-class competition, as we’ve seen in recent times the quality of the rugby has been outstanding,” he told reporters.
“So we believe it’s a competition that’s got a future, what that might look like is something that we’re always revisiting and looking at.”
Super Rugby scramble for solutions
RA look for government bailout
Pay cuts are a possibility
Officials scramble for answers
Super Rugby Team of the Week:
Lions join Bulls in isolation
Bulls set for self-isolation
Super surge all for nothing?
Dobson: ‘Job security concerns’
Super Rugby faces season cancellation