Player ratings: Big wobble

Australia will reflect on what may well be their Annus horribilis, finishing with the ignominy of becoming Argentina's first victims.

The Pumas' 21-17 win in Mendoza on Saturday again showed up the glaring weakness i a Wallaby team in regress.

Their set pieces, especially the scrums, are a mess. Their discipline is woeful and perhaps it relates to the much-reported public spat between players and certain management officials.

But generally, they just don't seem to be a cohesive unit that will be a threat at the World Cup next year.

Jan de Koning rates the Australian players!

15 Israel Folau:

Troubled the Puma defenders, especially when coming closer to the breakdown areas and not just hovering out wide.

7/10

14 Adam Ashley-Cooper:

One of the few Wallabies to have not harmed his reputation – a real stalwart.

7/10

13 Tevita Kuridrani:

Again very powerful with ball in hand, but the rest of his game can do with some improvement.

6/10

12 Matt Toomua:

Some great work on defence and certainly put his body on the line. However, slipped a few too many tackles and left the field after half-an-hour.

6/10

11 Joe Tomane:

A day he would rather forget. No real chances on attack and was largely anonymous.

5/10

10 Bernard Foley:

His shockers when having penalty kicks at goal shows he probably doesn't have the temperament to be a world class international.

4/10

9 Nick Phipps:

Silly mistake that resulted in a yellow card, when his team was already on a general warning, and he also seems to talk more than he plays.

4/10

8 Scott Higginbotham:

Had a point to prove and showed why he is probably a better option as first-choice No.8. Faded a bit in the latter stages.

6/10

7 Michael Hooper (captain):

You can always bank on him to make an impact at the breakdown, but his lack of discipline cost his team dearly.

4/10

6 Scott Fardy:

Other than his defensive work, he was nowhere to be found.

5/10

5 James Horwill:

Provided the grunt the Wallabies needed, with plenty of tackles and won all his line-outs. But, like many others in his team, were penalised too often.

6/10

4 Sam Carter:

Had a very ordinary day at the office.

5/10

3 Sekope Kepu:

Made plenty of tackles, but his poor set-piece work made him a liability.

4/10

2 Saia Fainga'a:

He did work hard on defence, but otherwise made absolutely not impact.

5/10

1 James Slipper:

Faded as the game went on, probably a result of being scrummed into submission.

4/10

Replacements:

16 Josh Mann-Rea (on for Fainga'a, 71st min):

Not enough time to be rated.

17 Benn Robinson (on for Slipper, 58th min):

Got shunted around in the scrums and his workrate was also poor.

4/10

18 Ben Alexander (on for Kepu, 58th min):

Absolutely no impact in any aspect.

4/10

19 Will Skelton (on for Horwill, 67th min):

Not enough time to be rated.

20 Jake Schatz (on for Higginbotham, 58th min):

His performance was no more than acceptable. No real impact.

5/10

21 Matt Hodgson:

Not used.

22 Nic White (on for Phipps, 63rd min):

The tide had begun to turn by the time he arrived on the field and struggled to make an impact.

5/10

23 Rob Horne (on for Toomua, 30th min):

Always gets about and made a huge contribution on defence, although his attacking options were limited.

6/10

ADVERTISEMENT

Join free

KOKO Show | November 4th | Ugo Monye Has a Ball on KOKO After England’s Big Win Over the Wallabies

Tests of Time: Ireland vs New Zealand - The absolute PEAK of sports history?

Embracing disability and sexuality | Lauren Rowles | Rugby Rising Locker Room | Season 3

Bohemia Rugby Warriors v Brussels Devils | Rugby Europe Super Cup 2025/26 | Full Match Replay

Lusitanos v Delta | Rugby Europe Super Cup 2025/26 | Full Match Replay

All 294 Tries in One EPIC Video | Every Rugby World Cup 2025 Try

Every England Try | Rugby World Cup 2025

Every Braxton Sorensen-McGee Try! Rugby World Cup 2025 Top Try Scorer

Write A Comment

Close

We've updated our Privacy Statement so you have more clarity and details regarding how and why we process your personal data.

We've also updated our Terms of Use. By continuing to use this website, you are accepting the updated Statement and Terms.