Get Newsletter

Ratings: England fall short

England arrived in Durban up for a tough match against South Africa and didn't back down from the physical challenge.

Having settled under coach Stuart Lancaster following a successful Six Nations with a young team that can take on anyone.

England came out firing and did a great job at the breakdown initially, but were unable to keep the South African's out in the second half when the backs started to find space to play with.

A try from ben Foden at the death will have given them some hope to bounce back next week.

Timmy Hancox rates the English players:

15 Mike Brown:

Did a good job fielding high balls at the back throughout the match and showed glimpses of what he can do on the counter-attack.

7/10

14 Chris Ashton:

Had one or two dangerous breaks, but was tackled from behind by Francois Hougaard and then Jean de Villiers, so his reputation for speed took a bit of a knock.

5/10

13 Manu Tuilagi:

Struggled to break the advantage line, but he still managed a few powerful runs and put in some strong tackles.

6/10

12 Brad Barritt:

The defensive pillar of the side, although he didn't offer much on attack. His tough tackling was badly missed after leaving the field injured.

7/10

11 Ben Foden:

Didn't see a lot of the action, but he did a great job to score the try at the end of the match to give his side some hope for the series.

7/10

10 Owen Farrell:

The young flyhalf looked up for a fight in the physical stuff and kicked for goal well, but didn't offer very much on attack and was pretty one dimensional with ball in hand.

5/10

9 Ben Youngs:

There was nothing wrong with his passing game, but he didn't find any hole to break on his usual sniping runs, while his kicking out of hand was poorly executed.

5/10

8 Ben Morgan:

Gave away several short-arm penalties at the scrum for triggering the engagement too early. He was also caught in possession at the back of a scrum and looked slow and ponderous at times.

4/10

7 Chris Robshaw (captain):

The skipper is a determined fellow and ran about the park making tackles and looking to turn the ball over wherever he could. Not a the best ball carrier, but he threw his body around for the sake of the team.

7/10

6 Tom Johnson:

He has a very busy debut and was effective on the ground winning turnovers in the first half, but faded a little later on. Not the best ball carrier either, but worked hard to make his presence felt.

7/10

5 Geoff Parling:

Did some great work in the line-outs, but didn't do a lot else to write home about.

6/10

4 Mouritz Botha:

SOme very good work counter-rucking and the South African-born player looked right at home in the physical stuff.

6/10

3 Dan Cole:

Made some good tackles in open play for a prop, but was under pressure at scrum time.

5/10

2 Dylan Hartley:

HIs line-out throwing was great, but his general play wasn't up to scratch and he looked more interested in niggling off the ball than playing rugby.

4/10

1 Joe Marler:

Very good in broken play, winning creating turnovers and hitting the rucks, but yet to prove himself in the scrums.

6/10

Replacements:

16 Lee Mears: (On for Dylan Hartley – 72nd minute)

Not long enough to be accurately rated

17 Paul Doran-Jones: (On for Joe Marler – 72nd minute)

Not long enough to be accurately rated

18 Tom Palmer: (On for Mouritz Botha – 58th minute)

Needed more time on the field to make a bigger impact, but he did add some value to the English engine room.

6/10

19 Phil Dowson: (On for Ben Morgan – 62nd minute)

Not long enough to be accurately rated

20 Lee Dickson: (On for ben Youngs – 72nd minute)

Not long enough to be accurately rated

21 Toby Flood: (On for Brad Barritt – 53rd minute)

Miss a few tackles, but has sturding in the midfield.

5/10

22 Jonathan Joseph: (On for Mike Brown – 78th minute)

Not long enough to be accurately rated

ADVERTISEMENT

Join free

Yokohama Canon Eagles vs Toshiba Brave Lupus Tokyo | Japan Rugby League One 2024/25 | Full Match Replay

Edinburgh vs Glasgow | Celtic Challenge 2024/25 | Match Highlights

Boks Office | Episode 31 | Investec Champions Cup Review

Global Schools Challenge | Day 2 Replay

The Backyard Bunch | The USA's Belmont Shore

AUSTRALIA vs USA behind the scenes | HSBC SVNS Embedded | E04

South Africa v France | HSBC SVNS Cape Town 2024 | Men's Final Match Highlights

Two Sides - Behind the scenes with the British & Irish Lions in South Africa | E01

Write A Comment