Blunt Boks still searching for a spark
OPINION: France and Ireland have beaten the Springboks at their own game in recent weeks and South Africa will have everything to prove in the coming Nations Championship final.
The Boks have lost to France and Ireland in recent weeks, recording back-to-back defeats for the first time since 2022.
The manner of those losses has been especially disappointing, and the stats don’t paint an especially flattering picture of the group’s approach and mindset.
The team hasn’t been the same since it won the Rugby’s Greatest Rivalry series against the All Blacks earlier this year.
The Boks have lost three of their last four matches, including the 38-42 defeat to Australia in Perth.
Some perspective is needed, of course.
The Boks have already realised their biggest goals for 2026 – by winning the Greatest Rivalry series 3-1, and by using 72 players over the course of the season and bolstering their depth a year out from the 2027 World Cup.
And in spite of recent results in Europe, they remain in the running for the Nations Championship title, with the final against France scheduled for next Sunday at Twickenham.
The latest chapter in this story has been messy and underwhelming, but may yet conclude with Bok skipper Siya Kolisi lifting another trophy.
That outcome, of course, will hinge on the coaches and players’ abilities to learn from recent mistakes.
Sure, the Boks could finish the season with their main objectives realised, and may declare that their plans for a third-successive World Cup title remain on track.
And yet, the nature of the defeats in Paris and Dublin deserves scrutiny.
Indeed, these results could signify a more serious problem if the team doesn’t bounce back to win the final – or to put it another way, if they don’t avoid the embarrassment of a third-straight loss for the first time since 2021.
TAKING ACCOUNTABILITY
Rassie Erasmus should be lauded for pointing out the flaws and inconsistencies of the World Rugby protocols.
If the Bok coach had stopped short of his “match-fixing” comments this past Monday, he would have accompanied the team to the Aviva Stadium on Saturday, instead of copping a six-match ban and watching the game from the team hotel.
In that scenario, Erasmus would have been in the change room at half-time, making plans and tactical changes.
In that event, the Boks may have turned things around to win, instead of losing 17-20.
But the players also need to be held accountable for the recent results and performances – and for the fact that France and Ireland have beaten the Boks at their own game.
The scrum remains their greatest weapon, and the Boks have lived up to the set-piece hype on this tour, forcing 11 penalties across three matches.
While many feel that the Boks deserved more reward for their dominance, can a team really expect to receive more than four penalties on average per match?
You have to feel for Ox Nché, Malcolm Marx, Wilco Louw and the rest of the front-row club, who have delivered week after week, only to be let down by their teammates in other areas.
Crucially, the Boks have lost the battle at the gain line over the past two weeks.
While there have been moments of brilliance – such as Marx’s surge for the tryline and the last-gasp defensive interventions of Cameron Hanekom and Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu in Dublin – they have failed to control this area and have paid a heavy price.
France (30) kicked more than the Boks (26) in Paris, while Ireland (24) also edged the South Africans (22) in this department.
The quality and accuracy of those kicks is important, and it would be fair to say that France as well as Ireland won the territorial battle and aerial contest.
Aaron Grandidier-Nkanang rose to the occasion in Paris, while the likes of Robert Baloucoune and Mack Hansen out-leapt the Boks in Dublin.
France and Ireland neutralised one of the Boks’ greatest strengths, while reaping the benefits on the breaking ball, and punishing a fractured South African defence.
It’s usually the Boks who instigate and thrive in these chaotic game situations, but in recent weeks, they have been on the receiving end of a well-executed kicking strategy.
The story continues below…
MISFIRING ATTACK
The attack has come in for heavy criticism, due to the team’s poor conversion rate in recent Tests.
While the Boks fought hard to stay in the contest in Dublin – and had the field position and the opportunities to force an unlikely win at the death – they were repeatedly undone by their poor handling and game management.
The line-out malfunctioned in the second half, to the point where the fallback strategy of marching upfield via a scrum penalty and subsequent line-out maul was compromised.
And when the Boks did manage to win the throw, their maul was stopped or their ball-carriers in the midfield were repelled by the well-drilled defence.
The Boks have developed a reputation as an all-court team in this four-year cycle, but the limp and rudderless performance in Dublin was tough to watch.
It was an uncharacteristic display by a team that has put 40 or more points on England, Scotland, Wales, New Zealand and Italy this season.
The outcome in Paris may have been different had Manie Libbok slotted a late conversion, and if one more 22 entry had resulted in a try in Dublin.
But there were times this past Saturday when the Boks seemed reluctant to play with the same energy and spirit that has marked them as the leading team on the planet for the past few years.
You have to credit France and Ireland for doing their homework and neutralising so many of South Africa’s strengths – but the bottom line is that the Bok players and coaches have failed to live up to their own standards on this tour.
FOLLOWING ENGLAND’S LEAD
It remains to be seen whether they can get it right against France in the Nations Championship final.
They will need to up the ante at the gain line and deliver a more accurate showing under the high ball to stand a chance against a rampant Les Bleus outfit.
The line-out will be under pressure, and one wonders whether the coaches will revise the decision to start Marx, given his importance at the back end of matches.
The alternative is to ask the big man to go 80 minutes in the last game of a long and gruelling season.
Either way, they can’t have another situation where Marx is watching the game from the bench at the death.
Having come through the series against the All Blacks, halfbacks Morné van den Berg and Feinberg-Mngomezulu face another test of mettle in a title-on-the-line scenario.
The Boks could be without a few players due to injuries, and have already lost No.8 Jasper Wiese to suspension.
Discipline has been an issue on this tour, with the Boks leaking a season high of 11 penalties against France as well as Ireland.
And after delivering a relatively clean performance in previous Tests this season, the Boks have conceded two reds, with Wiese sent off in Paris and Marco van Staden in Dublin.
The Boks need a spirited response in the coming final, but they also have to ensure that they keep 15 men on the park.
England married power with panache in their recent 37-12 demolition of the All Blacks, and that is the type of controlled aggression South Africa will need to win the Nations Championship decider.
It’s been a long and gruelling year, and the Boks have achieved so much already.
But their 2026 campaign will be marred if they produce another uninspired performance in London this coming weekend, and crash to a fourth defeat in the space of five games.
One more push, of course, may ensure that they end 2026 with more silverware and with their reputations well and truly burnished.
The HSBC SVNS series heads to DHL Stadium in Cape Town on 5-6 December! Get your tickets now
