Player Ratings: Ireland
OPINION: Ireland player ratings: Could this Nations Championship match ever have lived up to the expectations after one of the most bitter pre-match weeks between these two sides in living memory?
It did.
Much of the game played out like a brutal man-up-a-thon, with neither side giving an inch and Ireland desperately trying to survive the scrums in order to launch attacks, and for the most part, doing so.
A hugely gutsy performance from this Ireland side, who refused to be written off.
Final score 20-17 to Ireland.
15 Hugo Keenan – 7.5
Back at fullback, he dealt with an early Sacha Feinbergi-Mngomezulu ball over the top well, shepherding it into touch cool as a cucumber and followed that up with another great aerial take on 13 minutes. A breakneck cover scramble on 31 minutes saved Ireland’s bacon, but only temporarily, as they went on to score. His second half was scrappier, with a few errors creeping in.
14 Robert Baloucoune – 9
Has had an effective November to date and opened Ireland’s account here thanks to a fantastic, floated pass from Stuart McCloskey, which he finished superbly. Got a little greedy on 16 minutes, going for glory with Baird outside him, botching a five-pointer. It wasn’t just attack either, he was convincing aerially too. Possibly guilty of overplaying his hand at times but it couldn’t take away from a breakout performance.
13 Robbie Henshaw – 8
A phenomenal set of carries opening his account – full of piss and vinegar. Took a brutal accidental boot to his ear on 27 minutes that opened him up. But this was Henshaw at his battling, bloodied best.
12 Stuart McCloskey – 8
As with his centre partnership, had an outstanding opening, putting Baloucoune away for Ireland’s first and charging hard through Springbok defenders. A superb day out for the Ulsterman.
11 Mack Hansen – 7.5
Reverts to the wing after slotting in at fullback against Fiji last weekend. Did superbly to basketball the assist for Ireland’s second try. Kicked a remarkable touchfinder on the gallop on 41 minutes and generally added value very time he was on the ball. Missed a few too many tackles to score any higher.
10 Sam Prendergast – 7
Having escaped further punishment for his hip-drop tackle against Fiji, with Rassie Erasmus’ subsequent comments thrown into the bag, the spotlight was very much on Prendergast. Some of his decision-making here felt a little too risk-tolerant, but a good touchfinder on 38 minutes gave his pack a shot at glory and they took it. Far from perfect, but Ireland looked the more threatening team for much of this and he’s due credit.
9 Jamison Gibson-Park – 7
The man on Ireland’s steering wheel didn’t show any of the rust you might expect given it was only his fourth game back from injury. Understood the need to press the pace against the South Africans and was singled out for specialist treatment off the ball too. Run over by Canan Moodie, but thankfully for Ireland the try was scrubbed off. Charged down on 71 minutes but Eben Etzebeth was found to be offside.
8 Dan Sheehan – 7
Back on the field but in the less familiar role of No.8, Sheehan again proved he’s more than adept at the position. Fumbled a very hard ball to fetch overhead crossfield from Prendergast. Cleaned up some loose ball after halftime and very nearly turned it into an attacking opportunity down the right flank. Replaced by Timoney on 43 minutes, having been Ireland’s leading carrier up until that point. Returned following an injury for Timoney and was held up over the line on 61 minutes. Yellow-carded for a croc-roll with eight minutes left.
7 Josh van der Flier – 6.5
It was hardly a leading role here for van der Flier, who maybe faded into the background a little. No lack of effort, however, but there weren’t a lot of highlight-reel moments here, making just six metres from nine carries. Plenty of unseen stuff and was absolutely dogged at the breakdown all evening and ended the game with one of Ireland’s highest tackle counts.
6 Ryan Baird – 7
His early carries were largely ineffective against a white wall of Bok forwards who weren’t interested in offering any soft shoulders. Excelled where he so often does, at the lineout time. Maybe lucky to get away with a high-ish looking tackle on 53 minutes, referee Christophe Ridley adjudging there was no more he could do.
5 Tadhg Beirne – 6.5
In the trenches in the first half of this contest and worried the South African try line on two separate Ireland drives. It was a job of work to go toe to toe with this Saffa pack, but he never gave an inch. Took a Marco van Staden hit to the head too.
4 Joe McCarthy – 8
Won a big turnover on 17 minutes to raucous cheer – it was one Ireland needed after Baloucoune’s botched try attempt minutes earlier. Pinged for offside on 33 minutes, living life as a rugby edgelord. The Boks must have felt like they were facing one of their own.
3 Tadhg Furlong – 8
First scrum penalty went to the Springboks, but it was a bloodless coup, the second also, care of Porter folding on his far side. It was survival mode until a huge scrum at 26 minutes nearly took the roof off the Aviva. In truth every scrum was a cliffhanger and sure enough the Bok pressure returned just before halftime, with Furlong’s side buckling. But context is everything in ratings, and it’s hard to have expected any more from the Wexford man.
2 Rónan Kelleher – 7
Had a wobbly start at lineout time, an area of the game Ireland desperately needed to work on. Pinged for not releasing on 20 minutes in Ireland’s 22. Made up for his fairly mediocre first forty by beating the Boks cover to score off a relatively simple blindside lineout move. Put in a few thunderous hits around the park, including one on Pieter Steph du Toit.
1 Andrew Porter – 7
Porter collapsed on the second scrum, which was the omen no Irish supporter wanted to see. Penalised twice in the first half, but it was survival that needed to happen for Ireland to stand a chance, and he did that. As with Furlong, he deserves huge credit for his efforts.
Replacements – 6
Bundee Aki had a brief first-half cameo as a blood replacement for a battered Henshaw, but it was short-lived before he came back on in the second half, missing a tackle on Malcolm Marx on his way over for the Boks’ second try. Nick Timoney added physical venom after coming on, a huge hit turning over the ball on 52 minutes to kill a Bok attack dead. Thomas Clarkson did a respectable job at scrum time, winning one penalty and conceding another. Ryan and Stewart contributed, while even O’Toole took a pasting at scrumtime.

Watch Hemispheres collide as North faces South in the Nations Championship. Live matches, replays and highlights free on RugbyPass TV here
(*USA only)