Do Not Sell My Personal Information
RugbyPass Match Centre
Scores
Sorry there are no live games.
See what's coming up.
Springboks Green SRAGRE Gold SRAGOL Sat
3 Oct
5:00pm SAST
Bay of Plenty BAY Auckland AUC Fri
2 Oct
8:00am SAST
Counties COU Manawatu MAN Sat
3 Oct
3:00am SAST
Northland NOR Taranaki TAR Sat
3 Oct
5:15am SAST
Canterbury CAN Wellington WEL Sat
3 Oct
8:00am SAST
Southland SOU Waikato WAI Sun
4 Oct
3:00am SAST
North Harbour HAR Tasman TAS Sun
4 Oct
3:00am SAST
Otago OTA Hawke's Bay HAW Sun
4 Oct
5:15am SAST
Manawatu MAN Canterbury CAN Fri
9 Oct
8:00am SAST
North Harbour HAR Hawke's Bay HAW Sat
10 Oct
3:00am SAST
Taranaki TAR Auckland AUC Sat
10 Oct
3:00am SAST
Wellington WEL Otago OTA Sat
10 Oct
5:15am SAST
Waikato WAI Counties COU Sat
10 Oct
8:00am SAST
Tasman TAS Bay of Plenty BAY Sun
11 Oct
2:10am SAST
Northland NOR Southland SOU Sun
11 Oct
2:10am SAST
Hawke's Bay HAW Northland NOR Fri
16 Oct
8:00am SAST
Manawatu MAN Bay of Plenty BAY Sat
17 Oct
3:00am SAST
Wellington WEL North Harbour HAR Sat
17 Oct
3:00am SAST
Auckland AUC Tasman TAS Sat
17 Oct
5:15am SAST
Southland SOU Taranaki TAR Sat
17 Oct
8:00am SAST
Otago OTA Counties COU Sun
18 Oct
2:10am SAST
Canterbury CAN Waikato WAI Sun
18 Oct
2:10am SAST
Otago OTA Northland NOR Fri
23 Oct
8:00am SAST
Bay of Plenty BAY Canterbury CAN Sat
24 Oct
3:00am SAST
Hawke's Bay HAW Manawatu MAN Sat
24 Oct
5:15am SAST
North Harbour HAR Auckland AUC Sat
24 Oct
8:00am SAST
Tasman TAS Southland SOU Sun
25 Oct
3:00am SAST
Counties COU Wellington WEL Sun
25 Oct
3:00am SAST
Waikato WAI Taranaki TAR Sun
25 Oct
5:15am SAST
Canterbury CAN Otago OTA Fri
30 Oct
8:00am SAST
Wellington WEL Tasman TAS Sat
31 Oct
3:00am SAST
Northland NOR North Harbour HAR Sat
31 Oct
5:15am SAST
Auckland AUC Waikato WAI Sat
31 Oct
8:00am SAST
Manawatu MAN Southland SOU Sun
1 Nov
3:00am SAST
Bay of Plenty BAY Hawke's Bay HAW Sun
1 Nov
3:00am SAST
Taranaki TAR Counties COU Sun
1 Nov
5:15am SAST
Southland SOU Otago OTA Fri
6 Nov
8:00am SAST
Auckland AUC Northland NOR Sat
7 Nov
3:00am SAST
North Harbour HAR Counties COU Sat
7 Nov
5:15am SAST
Tasman TAS Canterbury CAN Sat
7 Nov
8:00am SAST
Hawke's Bay HAW Wellington WEL Sun
8 Nov
3:00am SAST
Waikato WAI Bay of Plenty BAY Sun
8 Nov
3:00am SAST
Manawatu MAN Taranaki TAR Sun
8 Nov
5:15am SAST
Counties COU Southland SOU Fri
13 Nov
8:00am SAST
Northland NOR Waikato WAI Sat
14 Nov
3:00am SAST
Otago OTA Tasman TAS Sat
14 Nov
5:15am SAST
Wellington WEL Manawatu MAN Sat
14 Nov
8:00am SAST
Bay of Plenty BAY North Harbour HAR Sun
15 Nov
3:00am SAST
Taranaki TAR Hawke's Bay HAW Sun
15 Nov
3:00am SAST
Canterbury CAN Auckland AUC Sun
15 Nov
5:15am SAST
Wed 28 Aug 2019 | 05:16

Law discussion: maul and afterwards

Law discussion: maul and afterwards
Wed 28 Aug 2019 | 05:16
Law discussion: maul and afterwards
SHARE

After a lineout on England’s right, George Ford, England’s flyhalf, kicks high towards his left. England chase, Jordan Larmour of Ireland catches the ball and immediately Elliot Daly and Owen Farrell grab Larmour.

ADVERTISEMENT

Bundee Aki is the first member of the Ireland team to join in to help Larmour, followed by Sean Cronin. Manu Tuilagi and Maro Itoje of England join in and the English players succeed in keeping Larmour on his feet.

The referee blows his whistle because it seems that play cannot develop. He makes a gesture of catching the ball and indicates a scrum with Ireland to put the ball in.

Farrell. England’s captain, disputes the decision, but the scrum goes to Ireland.

Who was right – referee or Farrell?

For the answer, we must look to the law.

LAW DEFINITION
Maul: A phase of play consisting of a ball-carrier and at least one player from each team, bound together and on their feet.

ADVERTISEMENT

Ball-carrier: Larmour
England player: Daly
Irish player: Aki
All on feet

Therefore it was a maul.

If play goes on away from the maul, the maul is said to end successfully.
If the referee stops play with the ball still in the maul, the maul is said to end unsuccessfully.

This maul ends unsuccessfully.

ADVERTISEMENT

Law 16.7 says that, when a maul ends unsuccessfully, a scrum is ordered.

This is what happens here. But whose ball is it? That’s what Farrell was disputing.

Law 19.1 SCRUM deals with who gets the put-in.

The abbreviated laws have a table. We give its requirements here.

Stoppage: A maul that ends unsuccessfully.
Who throws in: The team not in possession at the start of the maul.

That would suggest that it should be England’s ball. BUT….

Stoppage: An unplayable maul after kick in open play.
Who throws in: The team in possession at the start of the maul.

That confirms that the referee was right. England kicked, Ireland had possession when the maul commenced, i.e. when Aki joined Larmour and Daly.

The referee was right and Farrell was wrong to suggest otherwise. He was also wrong to dispute the referee’s decision.

Law 9 MISCONDUCT
Players must respect the authority of the referee. They must not dispute the referee’s decisions.
Sanction: Penalty.

Because Farrell was England’s captain did not give him the right to dispute the referee’s decision. In fact there is nothing in law that even allows the referee to ask a question of the referee or obliges the referee to give a reply. It is the custom that referees allow the captain to ask the reason for a decision and referees give him the courtesy of a reply. But there must be no dispute.

It has been like that since 1896!

The law that Farrell clearly did not know is not new nor is it unusual.

@rugby365com

PV: 2246
ADVERTISEMENT
Law discussion: maul and afterwards | Rugby365