Do Not Sell My Personal Information
RugbyPass Match Centre
Scores
Sorry there are no live games.
See what's coming up.
Bulls BUL Sharks SHA Sat
26 Sep
4:25pm SAST
Lions LIO Stormers STO Sat
26 Sep
6:55pm SAST
Wellington WEL Bay of Plenty BAY Fri
25 Sep
9:00am SAST
Tasman TAS Waikato WAI Sat
26 Sep
4:00am SAST
Southland SOU North Harbour HAR Sat
26 Sep
6:15am SAST
Hawke's Bay HAW Canterbury CAN Sat
26 Sep
9:00am SAST
Auckland AUC Manawatu MAN Sun
27 Sep
3:00am SAST
Taranaki TAR Otago OTA Sun
27 Sep
3:00am SAST
Counties COU Northland NOR Sun
27 Sep
5:15am SAST
Bay of Plenty BAY Auckland AUC Fri
2 Oct
8:00am SAST
Counties COU Manawatu MAN Sat
3 Oct
3:00am SAST
Northland NOR Taranaki TAR Sat
3 Oct
5:15am SAST
Canterbury CAN Wellington WEL Sat
3 Oct
8:00am SAST
Southland SOU Waikato WAI Sun
4 Oct
3:00am SAST
North Harbour HAR Tasman TAS Sun
4 Oct
3:00am SAST
Otago OTA Hawke's Bay HAW Sun
4 Oct
5:15am SAST
Manawatu MAN Canterbury CAN Fri
9 Oct
8:00am SAST
Taranaki TAR Auckland AUC Sat
10 Oct
3:00am SAST
Wellington WEL Otago OTA Sat
10 Oct
5:15am SAST
Waikato WAI Counties COU Sat
10 Oct
8:00am SAST
Tasman TAS Bay of Plenty BAY Sun
11 Oct
3:00am SAST
North Harbour HAR Hawke's Bay HAW Sun
11 Oct
3:00am SAST
Northland NOR Southland SOU Sun
11 Oct
5:15am SAST
Hawke's Bay HAW Northland NOR Fri
16 Oct
8:00am SAST
Manawatu MAN Bay of Plenty BAY Sat
17 Oct
3:00am SAST
Auckland AUC Tasman TAS Sat
17 Oct
5:15am SAST
Southland SOU Taranaki TAR Sat
17 Oct
8:00am SAST
Canterbury CAN Waikato WAI Sun
18 Oct
3:00am SAST
Otago OTA Counties COU Sun
18 Oct
3:00am SAST
Wellington WEL North Harbour HAR Sun
18 Oct
5:15am SAST
Otago OTA Northland NOR Fri
23 Oct
8:00am SAST
Bay of Plenty BAY Canterbury CAN Sat
24 Oct
3:00am SAST
Hawke's Bay HAW Manawatu MAN Sat
24 Oct
5:15am SAST
North Harbour HAR Auckland AUC Sat
24 Oct
8:00am SAST
Tasman TAS Southland SOU Sun
25 Oct
3:00am SAST
Counties COU Wellington WEL Sun
25 Oct
3:00am SAST
Waikato WAI Taranaki TAR Sun
25 Oct
5:15am SAST
Canterbury CAN Otago OTA Fri
30 Oct
8:00am SAST
Wellington WEL Tasman TAS Sat
31 Oct
3:00am SAST
Northland NOR North Harbour HAR Sat
31 Oct
5:15am SAST
Auckland AUC Waikato WAI Sat
31 Oct
8:00am SAST
Bay of Plenty BAY Hawke's Bay HAW Sun
1 Nov
3:00am SAST
Manawatu MAN Southland SOU Sun
1 Nov
3:00am SAST
Taranaki TAR Counties COU Sun
1 Nov
5:15am SAST
Southland SOU Otago OTA Fri
6 Nov
8:00am SAST
Auckland AUC Northland NOR Sat
7 Nov
3:00am SAST
North Harbour HAR Counties COU Sat
7 Nov
5:15am SAST
Tasman TAS Canterbury CAN Sat
7 Nov
8:00am SAST
Waikato WAI Bay of Plenty BAY Sun
8 Nov
3:00am SAST
Hawke's Bay HAW Wellington WEL Sun
8 Nov
3:00am SAST
Manawatu MAN Taranaki TAR Sun
8 Nov
5:15am SAST
Mon 9 Jan 2017 | 11:22

Law discussion: Seeing Red

Law discussion: Seeing Red
Mon 9 Jan 2017 | 11:22
Law discussion: Seeing Red
SHARE

The heightened awareness of the danger of head injuries led to a recent promulgation and law change on the matter by World Rugby.

ADVERTISEMENT

The most obvious incident in Saracen's match with Exeter Chiefs happened just short of 11 minutes into the match in which both victim and perpetrator (one of the perpetrators at least) suffered. The victim (Geoff Parling) was taken off on a mobile stretcher and the perpetrator (Richard Barrington) sent off with a red card.

Exeter Chiefs win the ball back from a tackle/ruck and scrumhalf Will Chudley passes to lock Geoff Parling on his right. Brad Barritt, the Saracens inside centre, flies at Parling and his swinging left arm goes around Parling's neck, jerking his head back. Parling is sinking down when his head makes heavy contact with the right shoulder of prop Richard Barrington. Parling falls heavily to ground, apparently unconscious.

The referee stops play and consults the TMO. There are several replays of the incident while medics are attending to Parling, which took some 10 minutes.

The referee then sums up what he has seen – the high tackle by Barritt and the contact with Barrington's shoulder. He decides that the Barrington shoulder had been the more serious offence – direct contact with Parling's head and with force. He then shows Barrington a red card and apologises for doing so.

At no stage is there consideration of intent but rather a focus on what happened, which is wise though the World Rugby statement speaks of "knew or should have known". If you look at the incident it would seem that Barrett is full of intent and has every opportunity to adjust his line of attack, Barrington far, far less so. After all it is Barrett's action that pulls tall Parling's head down to the level of Barrington's shoulder.

The commentator's speak of "out of control" which is probably a translation of the "reckless" which World Rugby uses.

ADVERTISEMENT

World Rugby's Statement

From 3 January, two new categories of dangerous tackles will carry penalty offences to deter and eradicate high tackles:

Reckless tackle

A player is deemed to have made reckless contact during a tackle or attempted tackle or during other phases of the game if in making contact, the player knew or should have known that there was a risk of making contact with the head of an opponent, but did so anyway. This sanction applies even if the tackle starts below the line of the shoulders. This type of contact also applies to grabbing and rolling or twisting around the head/neck area even if the contact starts below the line of the shoulders.

Minimum sanction: Yellow card

Maximum sanction: Red card

Accidental tackle

When making contact with another player during a tackle or attempted tackle or during other phases of the game, if a player makes accidental contact with an opponent's head, either directly or where the contact starts below the line of the shoulders, the player may still be sanctioned. This includes situations where the ball-carrier slips into the tackle.

Minimum sanction: Penalty

ADVERTISEMENT

Law 10.4 (e) Dangerous tackling of an Opponent including: (i) a tackle or attempted tackle above the line of the shoulders even if the tackle starts below the line of the shoulders; (ii) grabbing and rolling/twisting around the head/neck area even if the contact starts below the line of the shoulders.

Lower End – 2 weeks

Medium Range – 6 weeks

Top End – 10+ weeks

(A dangerous tackle which results in a strike to the head shall result in at least a mid-end entry point sanction six weeks)

The dubious side of the referee's decision is that he did not take further sanction against Barritt, whose tackle was high and reckless and would surely have qualified for at least a yellow card.

It seems that the referee was considered wise for not sending Barritt off as preserved the match as a contest for sake of paying spectators.

The law tells the referee that he has to apply the laws fairly but it does not say that he is required to bend laws to ensure an entertaining contest.

The one good thing that came out of it was the reaction of the players.

There was no infantile pushing and shoving by angry Exeter Chiefs and clear distress from the start by the Saracens players and when Parling was being wheeled off an obviously solicitous Barrington went to him in a contrite gesture.

And then the Saracens coaches also accepted the red card as a fair decision.

In the match, there were altogether five cases of head damage.

PV: 16
ADVERTISEMENT
Law discussion: Seeing Red | Rugby365