Committed to improving scrummaging
Coaches from the Six Nations participating Unions have thrown their support behind the IRB’s commitment to address scrum issues at the elite level of the game.
Currently 60% of all scrums collapse in Tier 1 internationals and 40% of scrums are required to be reset while the average time taken to complete a scrum has risen from 41 seconds to 53 seconds. (That means that 20 scrums would take 17 minutes out of 80.)
Despite a slight decrease in the number of collapses and resets since the new engagement sequence was introduced last year, the IRB remains determined to tackle the issues and ensure that this critical facet of the game is a spectacle and a contest.
The forum was held in London on Tuesday and attended by Martin Johnson (England), Marc Lièvremont and Didier Retiere (France), Declan Kidney and Gert Smal (Ireland), Alessandro Troncon (Italy), Andy Robinson (Scotland), Warren Gatland (Wales), David Pickering (Six Nations chairman and chairman of IRB referee selection committee), John Feehan (Six Nations chief executive), Bill Beaumont (IRB vice-chairman), Mike Miller (IRB chief executive), Mark Egan (IRB head of development and performance), Paddy O’Brien (IRB referee manager), Rhys Jones (IRB game analyst).
At a highly positive and productive forum in London on Tuesday evening, coaches from England, France, Ireland, Italy, Scotland and Wales pledged to work with the IRB to deliver a stable scrum platform.
In addition to expressing their support for the scrum engagement sequence, the coaches also gave their backing to the IRB’s policy of the strict application of scrum law, including ensuring straight put-ins. The coaches also support the IRB policy which mandates that referees should crack down on illegal front-row binding with a collective emphasis on ensuring that the tighthead prop binds on the body of the loosehead prop and not the arm and the loosehead prop adopts the correct body position and binds on the body of the opposition tighthead.
This collaborative approach will be critical in assisting to address the problematic aspects of the scrum. Last year a similar approach agreed by all Tier 1 coaches led to a crackdown in key areas of law: offside at the breakdown, offside from kicks, illegal maul formation and strict application of the tackle law. This resulted in a return to attacking Rugby.
Paddy O’Brien said: “The meeting was extremely constructive and highly productive. All found it beneficial and it was encouraging to see universal agreement from the coaches about the need to continue to penalise the clear and the obvious in the five key areas of law and in particular the need to address the scrum issues that are currently experienced at elite level.
“We are encouraged that teams recognise there is a collective responsibility to ensure that the high number of collapses and resets is reduced. The coaches expressed their full support for referees to employ a zero tolerance policy towards engagement offences and have given a commitment that their teams will endeavour to be compliant in producing a stable, steady scrum by binding correctly. The scrum is an integral facet of the game and by working together we can target the issues while ensuring that player welfare continues to be the most important consideration.”
A directive will be issued to all Unions reinforcing the message. The coaches forum has become a regular fixture ahead of the Six Nations, Tri-Nations, June and November Tests and underscores the IRB’s commitment to an open and transparent process of collaboration and communication between the IRB and its Member Unions in all areas of refereeing practice.
The following stats were produced at the forum:
Average scrums per match = 16:
Average collapses per match = 9,
Average resets per match = 6,
Average penalties/free kicks per match = 5.2
The 2009 Six Nations had the highest reset rate with 47 per 100 scrums
The 2010 Six Nations had the highest collapse rate with 67 per 100 scrums.
November 2009 had the lowest number of resets with 29 per 100 scrums and June 2009 had the lowest number of collapses with 47 per 100 scrums.
2009 Tri-Nations collapses on engagement 52 per 100 scrums, post engagement 39 per 100 scrums.
2010 Tri-Nations (current scrum sequence) collapses on engagement 25 per 100 scrums, post engagement 31 per 100 scrums.
Average time taken per scrum:
2009 Six Nations 43 seconds
2010 November 53 seconds.
In Round 6 of the Heineken Cup last weekend.
Racing-Métro vs Leinster: 14 scrums, 1 reset, 5 collapses, 3 penalties. (Only 1 out of 6 Leinster scrums collapsed.
Biarritz vs Bath: 18 scrums, 5 resets, 10 collapses, 4 penalties, 2 free kicks. (Duncan Bell, the Bath prop was given a yellow card at the thirds collapse and third penalty at a five-metre scrum.
Ospreys vs Toulon: 16 scrums, 7 resets, 6 collapses, 2 penalties, 3 free kicks
Castres vs Northampton Saints: 11 scrums, 6 resets, 4 collapses, 2 penalties
Leicester Tigers vs Treviso: 19 scrums (3 for Treviso), 8 resets, 13 collapses, 6 penalties, 1 free kick
Wasps vs Toulouse: 14 scrums, 7 resets, 6 collapses, 3 penalties and 1 free kick. It may be worth remarking that in this match the ball was put in noticeably straight and there were three heels against the head.
Totals: 92 scrums, 34 resets, 46 collapses, 20 penalties, 7 free kick
