Player ratings: Close, but no cigar

One defensive error at a scrum allowed Springbok scrumhalf Fourie du Preez to race over for a match-winning try five minutes from time – a 23-19 victory.

ADVERTISEMENT

It was heartbreaking, but perhaps the margin is a true reflection of how close it was – just one moment of magic from the Bok genius.

Jan de Koning rates the Welsh players!

15 Gareth Anscombe:

Only one decent run from the back, while he concede a couple of turnovers and also missed some tackles.

5/10

14 Alex Cuthbert:

His hands again let him down, as it has done throughout the tournament. Also missed a couple of tackle that cost his team.

5/10

13 Tyler Morgan:

Was very quiet. Other than a handful of tackles made no meaningful contribution.

5/10

12 Jamie Roberts:Player ratings: Close, but no cigar

His positional play was exceptional – as he thwarted a number of Bok attacks and cross-field kicks. His contesting in the air was great, although he missed a couple of tackles and conceded a penalty.

7/10

ADVERTISEMENT

11 George North:

A really impressive early run that put the Boks on the back foot and kept up his threatening play with ball in hand. Made all his tackles, but conceded a couple of penalties.

7/10

10 Dan Biggar:

His brilliance gave Wales their try. His kicking out of hands also kept Boks under pressure and unless he was injured, it was a huge blunder to replace him.

8/10

9 Gareth Davies:

His support play is exception and greatly contributed to Wales' try. His defending, however, left a lot to be desired.

6/10

8 Taulupe Faletau:

Physical with ball in hand, even though he was well-marked by the Boks, and made a mountain of tackles.

6/10

ADVERTISEMENT

7 Sam Warburton (captain):

Impressive work at the breakdown, on attack and defence, including some crucial turnovers. Close to being his team's most valuable forward.

8/10

6 Dan Lydiate:

His defence against the big Bok ball-carriers was impressive and he was also very efficient at the breakdown. Racked up the biggest tackle count in the game.

7/10

5 Alun-Wyn Jones:

The physical presence Wales required against SA, but missed a few tackles and also not as effective in the line-outs as the Welsh would have wanted.

6/10

4 Luke Charteris:

He made life unpleasant for the Boks when they attempted to set up their mauls – pushed the envelope and conceded a few penalties.

6/10

3 Samson Lee:

Solid in the scrums, but his workrate outside of the set pieces was very poor.

5/10

2 Scott Baldwin:Player ratings: Close, but no cigar

His best work was on defence and he was solid in the set pieces.

6/10

1 Gethin Jenkins.  

Worked hard on defence and solid in the scrums.

6/10

Replacements:

16 Ken Owens (on for Baldwin, 57th min):

Brought nothing mew – just steady and doing the same defensive work as Baldwin.

5/10

17 Paul James (on for Jenkins, 56th min):

He made some tackles, but otherwise made no impact.

5/10

18 Tom Francis (on for Lee, 56th min):

Absolutely no impact. Made a handful of tackles and kick-off held his ground in the scrums.

4/10

19 Bradley Davies (on for Charteris, 64th min):

Made his tackles and nothing more.

5/10

20 Justin Tipuric (on for Lydiate, 64th min):

Did not make the impact that was expected of him.

5/10

21 Lloyd Williams (on for Davies, 71st min):

Not enough time to be rated.

22 Rhys Priestland (on for Biggar, 73rd min):

Not enough time to be rated.

23 James Hook (on for Morgan, 68th min):

Not enough time to be rated.

@rugby365com

Player ratings: Close, but no cigarPlayer ratings: Close, but no cigar

Join free

KOKO Show | November 4th | Ugo Monye Has a Ball on KOKO After England’s Big Win Over the Wallabies

Tests of Time: Ireland vs New Zealand - The absolute PEAK of sports history?

Embracing disability and sexuality | Lauren Rowles | Rugby Rising Locker Room | Season 3

Bohemia Rugby Warriors v Brussels Devils | Rugby Europe Super Cup 2025/26 | Full Match Replay

Lusitanos v Delta | Rugby Europe Super Cup 2025/26 | Full Match Replay

All 294 Tries in One EPIC Video | Every Rugby World Cup 2025 Try

Every England Try | Rugby World Cup 2025

Every Braxton Sorensen-McGee Try! Rugby World Cup 2025 Top Try Scorer

Write A Comment

Close

We've updated our Privacy Statement so you have more clarity and details regarding how and why we process your personal data.

We've also updated our Terms of Use. By continuing to use this website, you are accepting the updated Statement and Terms.