Did Varsity Cup drop the ball?

Mon, 18 Apr 2016 14:35
Large varsity cup trophy2 800

EXCLUSIVE: The organisers of the Varsity Cup have found themselves staring down both barrels after further allegations have surfaced that newly-crowned champions NWU-Pukke may have fielded an ineligible player.

Throughout the 2016 tournament numerous participating Universities were docked points for fielding ineligible players, none more so than UKZN-Impi who were docked 12 points for the rule breach, which subsequently cost them a place in the promotion/relegation match.

The latest scandal involves a Pukke player, who represented the Impi in 2014. A reliable source linked with UKZN spoke to rugby365 to reveal their concerns.

"What has happened is that one of our former players was playing for Pukke. I never knew about him playing for them and was only made aware of it when I received a call from someone pointing it out to me.

"He was a registered student here in 2014, much in the same way that our player was at UJ. In our case, we submitted our full list of players at the start of the season, and we end up getting a letter from the auditors stating that all our players are good to play.

"Surely, they [the auditors] should have picked up that our player had played for UJ Young Guns in 2014 and everything would have been avoided.

"Varsity Cup should be given the chance to apply the precedent and the rules they have set. We just want fairness and the same rule of thumb to be applied across the board. I don't really see what the differences in the cases are," the source stated.

However, Pukke believe that UKZN are clutching at straws as they feel everything is above board.

"The player concerned played for UKZN in 2014. He did not represent the Pukke in the 2015 Varsity Cup, however, he represented the Leopards in the Currie Cup First Division," a spokesperson for Pukke said.

Having gone through the competition rules and numerous clauses outlined in the official Varsity Cup media guide, the only rule which applies to the matter states the following:

Rule 4. Eligibility (Clause 8 of the Bye-Laws)

4.5.1. No student that was registered as a student at any Varsity Cup and/or Varsity Shield Member University as to referred to in Clauses 3.1 and 3.2 of the Varsity Cup Bye Laws ("Member University") and/or player that has played for any representative team at any Member University during a particular year, is allowed to play for a team of another Member University in any of the Competitions in the following year unless he is a newly enrolled post-graduate student at the University for which he wants to play, or unless he has been authorized in writing to play in terms of the provisions of Clause 8.9 of the Varsity Cup Bye-Laws. No player that is an enrolled bona fide student at a Member University may play for another Member University.

There is no doubt that there are glaring similarities in both cases. However, when looking at the applicable rule, both Universities seem to have played within the rules.

So who is at fault? The Universities or the Varsity Cup board themselves?

@rugby365com

There are currently no matches being played
FIXTURE GMT VENUE
Mon, 27 February 2017
UCT-Ikeys v Maties 14h45 Cape Town
Rhodes v Fort Hare 16h30 Grahamstown
CUT-Ixias v UJ 16h30 Bloemfontein
CPUT v UKZN-Impi 16h30 Cape Town
UWC v TUT 16h30 Cape Town
UP-Tuks v Wits 16h30 Pretoria
Shimlas v NWU-Pukke 17h00 Bloemfontein
Thu, 02 March 2017
Force v Reds 10h30 Perth
Fri, 03 March 2017
Chiefs v Blues 06h35 Hamilton
Connacht v Zebre 19h35 Ascoli Piceno
Ulster v Treviso 19h35 Kingspan Stadium
Edinburgh v Ospreys 19h35 Myreside
Sale Sharks v Northampton Saints 20h15 AJ Bell Stadium
Sat, 04 March 2017
Hurricanes v Rebels 04h15 Wellington
Highlanders v Crusaders 06h45 Dunedin
Brumbies v Sharks 08h45 Canberra
Sunwolves v Kings 10h55 Singapore
Lions v Waratahs 13h05 Johannesburg
Gloucester v Harlequins 15h00 Kingsholm
Leicester Tigers v Exeter Chiefs 15h00 Welford Road
Worcester Warriors v Bristol 15h00 Sixways
Bath v Wasps 15h00 Recreation Ground
Glasgow Warriors v Dragons 15h00 Scotstoun Stadium
Stormers v Jaguares 15h15 Cape Town
Cardiff Blues v Munster 17h15 BT Sport Cardiff Arms Park
Cheetahs v Bulls 17h30 Bloemfontein
Leinster v Scarlets 19h35 RDS Arena
Sun, 05 March 2017
Newcastle Falcons v Saracens 15h00 Kingston Park
VARSITY CUP
MORE LOGS
Pool CUP
Team P W D L Pts
Maties 4 3 0 1 14
Shimlas 4 3 0 1 14
NWU-Pukke 4 3 0 1 13
UP-Tuks 3 2 0 1 10
UCT-Ikeys 4 2 0 2 9
Wits 3 1 0 2 6
UJ 3 1 0 2 6
NMMU-Madibaz 4 1 0 3 5
CUT-Ixias 3 0 0 3 0
Pool SHIELD
Team P W D L Pts
WSU 3 3 0 0 14
UWC 3 2 0 1 12
Fort Hare 3 1 0 2 6
TUT 2 1 0 2 5
CPUT 2 1 0 1 5
UKZN-Impi 2 1 0 1 4
Rhodes 3 0 0 3 2